AQUIFER-PERFORMANCE TEST OF
THE RIO VALDIVIA ALLUVIAL AQUIFER AT CARRIZAL, ECUADOR, S.A.
William M. Turner, Ph.D.
INTRODUCTION
AGW hydrogeologists carried out a water resources evaluation of the Santa Elena Peninsula of
Ecuador for the Empressa Municipal de Agua Potable de Guayaquil (EMAP), funded by
the World Bank. The feasibility of ground-water extraction from the alluvial
deposits in the Rio Valdivia Valley was evaluated by means of a detailed and closely controlled
aquifer-performance test (APT). The test used an existing irrigation well at the
village of Carrizal as the production well. The site of the
test is shown in Figure 1.
|
Hydrogeologists in the Rio
Valdivia Valley |
APT DESIGN
The production well was drilled many years ago but had never been put into
production. The well was constructed of blank 20-inch (50.8 cm) diameter casing set
to a depth of about 16 feet (5 m) followed by 144 feet (44 m) of 20-inch (50.8 cm)
diameter, machine-slotted, filter-pipe. The string of filter-pipe and casing was
gravel packed to the land surface.
Because the water table in the river channel was close to the land surface at the time
of the test, observation wells were constructed from lengths of 1/2-inch (0.02 cm)
diameter, galvanized steel pipe. The pipes were slotted by hacksaw, and one end of
each pipe was flattened to form a drive point. The pipes were driven into the
aquifer with a jackhammer. We reasoned that, not
only were the observation points inexpensive, but the small amount of water storage in
them would eliminate well-bore storage effects.
We installed a 6-inch (15.2 cm) diameter, 1,600-foot (500 m) pipeline to the south of
the pumped well to prevent the pumped water from reentering the aquifer in the vicinity
test. The pipeline terminated at a network of irrigation ditches which conveyed the
produced water another 1,600 feet (500 m) to the south before returning it to the
aquifer.
PRE-TEST DATA COLLECTION
AGW hydrogeologists conducted a short-duration, constant-discharge, aquifer-performance
test (APT) using the Carrizal well to estimate the aquifer transmissivity and a
reasonable pumping rate for a large capacity, long-term test. We measured drawdown
with an etched steel tape graduated in l00ths of a foot. We made out measurements
within a 1/2-inch-diameter (1.27 cm) polyethylene tube suspended in the production
well.
We measured the pumping rate volumetrically with a 3-gallon (11.4 l/s) bucket and a
Clebar stopwatch graduated in l00ths of a second. We analyzed the time-drawdown data
using the Jacob, quasi-steady state, straight-line method. Based on this test, we
decided to pump the control well at 500 gpm (31.6 l/s).
We evaluated the ground-water-level response times of the observation wells by
introducing one-half liter of water into each observation well and measuring the time
required to reestablish the pre-injection water level. In all cases, original water
levels were reestablished within 30 seconds. We believe response of each of the
observation wells was satisfactory.
We measured water-level measurements in the production well over a period of 16 days
prior to initiation of the aquifer-performance test. The average rise in water level
immediately prior to the test was 0.090 ft/day (0.03 m/day).
THE TEST
We installed three pumps, each with a maximum, rated capacity of less than 200 gpm
(12.6 l/s) in the well. We controlled the discharge from each pump with a 3-inch
gate valve. The pumps were powered by a 3 kilowatt, 220-volt, 3-phase
generator. We turned on the first pump in the control well and it immediately became
apparent that the well could sustain a pumping rate of only 60 gpm (3.8 l/s). This
test was terminated after 3 hours 33 minutes. We turned on only on pump 15 minutes
later and its discharge rate was maintained at 60 gpm (3.8 l/s). The terminated the
test 1,082 minutes later because maintenance was required on the generator. We
obtained sufficient drawdown data for analysis from all of the observation wells during
the test.
DATA ANALYSIS
We plotted the data from the observation wells on 2-cycle logarithmic paper. We
analyzed the data using the Theis, transient state, non-equilibrium method.
Vertical ground-water flow in the vicinity of the control and observation wells is
negligible. Aquifer parameters determined from the tests are tabulated in Table
1.
Table 1. Summary of
aquifer parameters determined
from the aquifer-performance test at Carrizal.
Well |
Date
of Test |
Method |
Transmissivity
(gpd/ft) |
(m2/d) |
Storage
Coefficient |
Production |
6/25/74
|
Jacob
|
37,889
|
471
|
|
2A |
7/11/74 |
Theis |
37,999 |
472 |
0.047 |
3
|
7/11/74
|
Theis
|
41,256
|
512
|
.110
|
4A |
7/11/74 |
Theis |
63,030 |
783 |
.058 |
5A
|
7/11/74
|
Theis
|
40,747
|
506
|
.048
|
CONCLUSIONS
Our analysis of the data indicates the average aquifer transmissivity is about 40,000
gpd/ft (497 m2/d) and the average specific yield is about 0.05. We
conclude the aquifer is thin and will not yield water at high rates because drawdown
caused by pumping significantly reduces the saturated thickness in the vicinity of the
well. Our conclusion was subsequently verified by a thermal injection test of the
well.
If ground water is to be developed in the Valdivia valley, well points, shallow
hand-dug wells, Ranney-type collector wells, or infiltration galleries will be
required.
VERIFICATION
A British Overseas Geological Survey hydrologist convinced EMAP that the pumping well
and the observation wells had not been drilled and constructed properly. EMAP
subsequently drilled and constructed (at very considerable expense) two, large-diameter,
test wells and a co-linear network of eight observation wells equipped with automatic
water-level recorders about two kilometers downstream from Carrizal near the village of
Barcelona. Aquifer-performance tests using the two test wells were carried out by
personnel of the British Overseas Geological Survey. The conclusions reached were
that water from the aquifer was best produced by well points or an infiltration
gallery. These conclusions agreed with the conclusions reached earlier by AGW
scientists, using common-sense, small-diameter, observation-well installation, and a
thermal injection test for a fraction of the cost.
Top of Page
|